Compensation for Wrongfully Convicted Shows Lawmaking is Just the First Step

MPRN’s Cheyna Roth and WDET’s Jake Neher talk about the messy business of implementing and testing new laws.

State Capitol Dome March 2017

Photo credit: Jake Neher/WDET

Cheyna Roth/MPRN
Marwin McHenry, a wrongfully convicted former inmate, after a hearing this week in Detroit. He received over $175,000 after spending four years in prison.

For the first time, people in Michigan who were wrongfully convicted are receiving compensation for their time in prison.

The first hearings to grant compensation happened this week in Detroit.

WDET’s Jake Neher and Michigan Public Radio’s Cheyna Roth talk about how the hearings were a happy ending for some exonerated former inmates, “but not for everybody.”

“There were a couple of people, two of them, who went home having their cases essentially dismissed,” says Roth. That’s because those cases didn’t involve new evidence brought forth to prove innocence. Rather, those individuals were released due to legal errors in their initial trials.

Now, there are questions about whether it was state lawmakers’ intent to pass a law that excluded some former inmates who were determined to be wrongfully convicted.

Neher says this is a good example of how it’s easy to view new laws as permanent solutions to societal problems — “But, in reality, that’s just the beginning,” he says. “That’s just where we start to find out how these laws actually affect people.”

Roth and Neher go on to talk about how the court system is just as important a venue for citizen involvement and activism as the legislative and executive branches of government.

Click on the audio player above to hear the full conversation.

Authors

  • Cheyna Roth is the co-host and creator of WDET's state politics podcast, MichMash. She has been an audio journalist for almost a decade, covering major events like presidential elections, college scandals, the Michigan Legislature and more, appearing on NPR and across Michigan public radio stations. Cheyna is also a senior producer and podcast host for Slate.com, having produced and hosted shows like Political Gabfest, The Waves, and What Next TBD. Also an author, Cheyna has written two true crime books and her written work has appeared in Broadly, Slate, and MLive, among others.
  • Jake Neher is senior producer for Detroit Today and host of MichMash for 101.9 WDET. He previously reported on the Michigan Legislature for the Michigan Public Radio Network.