State House Approves Millage Money for Charter Schools

Opponents say it’ll take away from already cash-strapped traditional public schools in favor of for-profit institutions.

Hallway Orchard Lake Middle School West Bloomfield

Michigan House
State Rep. Tim Kelly (R-Saginaw)

The state House narrowly passed a charter school bill Thursday. It would let charter schools qualify for countywide tax millage dollars. That’s money that previously has gone to traditional public schools. The Senate bill has been waiting for a full House vote since last year.

State Rep. Tim Kelly (R-Saginaw) chairs the House Education Reform committee. He said all students should be treated equally.

“This is a basic fairness issue,” he said. “I mean if we’re concerned about all kids and treating them fairly and equitably across the board, then what’s good for traditional schools is good for charter schools.”

But a few Republicans sided with Democrats on this controversial issue.

Opponents say it’ll take away from already cash-strapped traditional public schools – in favor of for-profit institutions.

Rep. Darrin Camilleri (D-Brownstown) voted against the bill. He said charter school operators take money off the top to keep as profit.

“So in effect, SB 574 would take away millions of dollars meant for our public schools and put it right in the pockets of companies trying to profit off our kids’ education,” he said.

But Kelly wasn’t having it. He said the opposition is really to charter schools in general – and he’s sick of the argument.

“This is the law,” Kelly said. “These have been around, they’re legitimate, it’s working for thousands of Michigan students and families. Stop. Stop already.”

The bill needs a final technical vote in the Senate. Then it’s on its way to the governor’s desk. 

Author

  • Cheyna Roth is the co-host and creator of WDET's state politics podcast, MichMash. She has been an audio journalist for almost a decade, covering major events like presidential elections, college scandals, the Michigan Legislature and more, appearing on NPR and across Michigan public radio stations. Cheyna is also a senior producer and podcast host for Slate.com, having produced and hosted shows like Political Gabfest, The Waves, and What Next TBD. Also an author, Cheyna has written two true crime books and her written work has appeared in Broadly, Slate, and MLive, among others.