Less stick. More carrot. That appears to be Gov. Gretchen Whitmer’s approach now.
Last Wednesday, the governor visited Ford Field in Detroit, which currently serves as a mass vaccination site. Whitmer slipped her left arm out of her coat, and took her first Pfizer shot.
“The problem is fatigue, mobility and variants, and we’ve got all of those things working against us here in Michigan right now.” —Gov. Gretchen Whitmer
“I feel good. I feel relieved, to be honest,” she said afterward.
The event was timed to start reaching people who are reluctant to get vaccinated while Michigan faces a new surge in infections.
“The problem is fatigue, mobility and variants, and we’ve got all of those things working against us here in Michigan right now,” she said.
The shift in messaging follows political opposition and lawsuits challenging the governors continued use of shutdown orders and restrictions.
“For people who are reactant, restrictions can make it worse,” says Ken Resnicow, an expert in public health messaging at the University of Michigan.
He says some in the African American community are vaccine hesitant. Then there’s a core group that’s in the “hard no” camp. That group, he says, is largely made of white evangelical men who are ready to defy government health orders.
“And if you say you must, you should, you have to, they almost biologically want to go in the opposite direction … We have to be careful to respect their independence. That is the number one issue, is that this is an attempt to control me and, therefore, a threat to my independence which these people value very highly.”
Exhibit A might be Michigan Senate Majority Leader Mike Shirkey.
Last month, the state’s top Republican and Whitmer nemesis said it’s time to let people make more individual choices on how to respond to the threat of COVID-19.
“And they’re just waiting to be informed, inspired, encouraged and then trusted, and right now we’re still under an environment where this governor does not trust the citizens of Michigan to do the right thing,” he said.
Listen: How Gov. Gretchen Whitmer is following a new script.
But Resnicow says white evangelical conservatives like Shirkey can be reached. He says the messaging has to be focused on their choice to protect their family and their community.
“You have to be very careful to say that this is up to you, this is an important choice that you can make,” he said.
Resnicow is part of the Protector Coalition, a group of public health experts and professional storytellers in the entertainment industry.
He says the group is working up narratives and storylines to use in ads and TV shows to help create a culture shift across the political spectrum, one that embraces masks, distancing and vaccination.
Which is why, in Michigan, as Governor Whitmer ponders her next move amid the new COVID-19 wave, her first choice is not re-imposing restrictions, but following a new script.